top of page

Choosing The Right Game: A Friendly Guide to Board Game Selection

If you’re anything like me, the world of board games is a treasure trove of fun, strategy, and sometimes, a little friendly rivalry. But with so many options out there, how do you pick the perfect game for your next game night? Whether you’re hunting for a quick party game, a deep strategy challenge, or something that the whole family can enjoy, choosing the right board game can feel a bit overwhelming. Don’t worry, I’ve got your back! Let’s dive into the art of board game selection together.


Why Board Game Selection Matters More Than You Think


You might be wondering, “Isn’t any game good enough?” Well, yes and no. The right game can turn an ordinary evening into an unforgettable experience. The wrong one? Well, let’s just say it might lead to some awkward silences or a pile of untouched game pieces.


When choosing the right game, consider these key factors:


  • Player Count: Some games shine with two players, others need a crowd.

  • Game Length: Are you up for a quick 20-minute round or a marathon session?

  • Complexity: Do you want something easy to learn or a brain-bending challenge?

  • Theme and Style: From fantasy quests to economic simulations, the theme can make a big difference.

  • Age Range: Make sure the game suits everyone’s age and interests.


For example, if you’re planning a family game night with kids aged 8 and up, a game like Survive The Island offers simple rules and engaging gameplay. On the other hand, if you’re with a group of strategy buffs, Kinfire Council might be the perfect pick.

Kinfire Council
Kinfire Council - A heavier strategy game utilising worker placement and resource management.

How to Navigate the Maze of Board Game Selection


Let’s be honest - the sheer number of board games out there can be intimidating. But here’s a little secret: you don’t have to try them all to find the right one for you. Instead, focus on what matters most to you and your group.


Here’s a handy step-by-step approach:


  1. Identify Your Group’s Preferences: Are you playing with family, friends, or fellow enthusiasts? What do they enjoy?

  2. Set Your Time Frame: How long do you want the game to last? Short and sweet or epic and immersive?

  3. Check the Complexity Level: Beginners might prefer lighter games, while heavier gamers might crave something more challenging.

  4. Look for Themes That Spark Interest: Whether it’s deduction, adventure, or economics, the theme can make the game more engaging t the people you have coming to play.

  5. Read Reviews and Watch Playthroughs: Seeing the game in action can help you decide if it’s a fit. Or search here for mechanics or theme.

  6. Try Before You Buy: Try out a board game café to give a few you have shortlisted a go before you make the purchase.


If you’re ever stuck, I highly recommend checking out the search function in this website. All games reviewed which is hundreds, are tagged by their category, mechanics and theme, this may help you discover new games tailored to your tastes.


Do you really know your Family game?


Okay, I had to throw in a little pun there because family games are a whole different beast. You might think you know what your family likes, but sometimes the best way to find out is to experiment a bit.


Family games need to strike a balance between fun and accessibility. You want everyone to feel included, regardless of age or experience. Games like Qwirkle and 221b Baker Street, are classics for a reason, they’re easy to learn but offer enough depth to keep everyone interested.


But don’t shy away from newer or indie games either. Many independent creators design games with families in mind, often bringing fresh ideas and unique mechanics to the table. These games can be a breath of fresh air and a great way to support creative minds.


Here’s a quick tip: involve your family in the selection process. Ask what themes or types of games they enjoy. Maybe your kids love animals, search for animals on the site here and you will get plenty of choices. Check it out. Tailoring your choice to these interests can make game night something everyone looks forward to.

Kavango Board Game
Kavango not only plays well and looks gorgeous, it will also teach your family about conservation.

The Joy of Discovering Independent Board Games


One of the most exciting parts of board game selection is stumbling upon hidden gems from independent creators. These games often bring innovative mechanics, fresh themes, and a personal touch that big publishers might miss.


Supporting indie games like Kavango not only diversifies your collection but also helps foster a passionate community around the hobby. Plus, many indie games come with unique artwork and storytelling that can make your game nights truly special.


When trying out an indie game, keep an open mind. Some might have a steeper learning curve or unconventional rules, but that’s part of the charm. And if you love it, you’ll be part of a growing movement that celebrates creativity and innovation in board gaming.


Making Your Board Game Selection a Breeze


By now, you’re probably feeling more confident about picking your next game. Remember, the best board game is the one that brings joy, sparks laughter, and maybe even a little friendly competition.


Here are some final nuggets of wisdom to keep in mind:


  • Mix It Up: Don’t be afraid to try different genres and styles.

  • Consider Replayability: Games that offer new experiences each time keep things fresh.

  • Think About Your Space: Some games require a lot of room or special setups.

  • Budget Wisely: Great games come in all price ranges, so find what fits your wallet.

  • Have Fun: At the end of the day, it’s all about enjoying the time spent together.


If you ever feel overwhelmed, just remember that resources like our Search function are there to guide you. They make the process easier and more enjoyable, helping you find games that fit your unique tastes and needs.


So, next time you’re faced with a shelf full of options, take a deep breath, think about what you and your group love, and dive in. Your ideal board game is waiting to be discovered!


Happy gaming!

© 2025 Jim Gamer Hope you enjoy the ride! Don't forget, all links and shopping carts are affiliate links and help support the site if you purchase through them if your cookies are enabled. Thanks for your support. 

bottom of page